Circuit Appellate Opinions

Return to Circuit Opinions

To view Circuit Opinions, select a topic from the dropdown box and click on apply.

Civil
Electronic Notice
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconHarari v. Whitford126.51 KB 006AP000054 05/25/2007
Eviction
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconBehar v. Louisdort31.95 KB 2007AP000188 10/17/2008
PDF iconLakeside Development v. D'Angelo Glades193.56 KB 2008AP000072 12/15/2009
PDF iconEdwards v. PBC Housing Authority51.89 KB 2010AP000066 08/03/2011
PDF iconSmith v. Nowak1 MB 2015AP000066 03/03/2017
PDF iconSimmonds v. Village Square Apts.633.6 KB 2018CC003252 06/19/2019
PDF iconMarkovich v. Jecoby237.86 KB 2019AP000207 11/30/2020
Evidence, Exclusion of
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconQuintana v. Financial Services Vehicle Trust1.56 MB 2018AP000047 02/21/2019
Experts
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconBoca View Condominium Association v. Edward Lepselter92.5 KB 2014AP000051 08/27/2015
PDF iconDavid Wall v. USAA91.64 KB 2014AP000049 11/13/2015
Fair Debt Collections Practices Act
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconFair Debt Collections Practices Act255.19 KB 2013AP000071 08/27/2015
Florida Consumer Collections Practices Act
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconMichael Murray v. Nationstar Mortgage220.3 KB 2016AP900008 10/25/2016
Insurance
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconFirst Empire Restorations v. Avatar Property & Casualty177.88 KB 2019AP000041 11/30/2020
Insurance (except PIP)
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconNationwide Mutual Fire v. The Sign Store91.58 KB 2009AP000026 04/07/2010
PDF iconBaltazar v. Baltimore Life Insurance Company1.74 MB 2016AP900304 02/02/2018
Judgment, Confession Of
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconState Farm v. Morrow258.64 KB 2009AP000067 01/11/2011
Judgment, Final
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconAlan v. Hardy46.24 KB 2007AP000126 10/18/2008
PDF iconBill's Electrical & Computer v. Aztil, Inc.776.41 KB 2007AP000190 12/19/2008
PDF iconDerek Wiley and Tracy Wiley v. Jupiter House LLC30.66 KB 2013AP000061 02/23/2015
Judgment, Notice
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconFlorida Caliper v. Carl Cascio, PA107.88 KB 2007AP000081 06/19/2008
PDF iconRB III Assoc., Inc. v. Anderson37.74 KB 2009AP000020 01/22/2010
PDF iconSalim v. Flynn159.92 KB 2011AP000013 05/15/2013
PDF iconChapman v. Cleveland212.25 KB 2019AP000037 06/29/2020
PDF iconFamily First v. MROD218.45 KB 2019AP000116 09/09/2020
Judgment, Summary
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconGarces v. Nationwide Home Equity Corp.109.66 KB 2008AP000024 07/29/2009
PDF iconCarter v. Palm Beach Sheriff's Office2.19 MB 2016AP900033 07/29/2009
PDF iconBoca East Animal Hospital v. Camp Canine53.03 KB 2010AP000012 08/20/2010
PDF iconLiberty Mutual v. Village Chiropractic203.97 KB 2010AP000002 02/24/2011
PDF iconKupritz v. Chase Bank111.44 KB 2010AP000062 03/26/2012
PDF icon24/7 Water Restoration v. Geovera Advantage Specialty Insurance114.89 KB 2015AP000031 06/16/2016
PDF iconStewart Agency v. Standard Fire Insurance Co.1.07 MB 2016AP900115 06/13/2017
PDF iconSwift Investments Inc. v. Allstate Property and Casualty1.2 MB 2016AP900182 08/04/2017
PDF iconSwift Investments v. USAA Casualty Ins. Co.1.31 MB 2017AP000066 05/03/2018
PDF iconValene v. Stefel200.04 KB 2019AP000038 09/16/2020
Liens
Case Case Number Date Filed
Mallard v. East Coast Recovery (withdrawn) 2016AP900116 02/07/2017
PDF iconMallard v. East Coast Recovery (on rehearing)1.8 MB 2016AP900116 04/13/2017
Proceedings Supplementary
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconBank of American v. Peth Southammovong39.02 KB 2009AP000005 12/04/2009
PDF iconRic Bradshaw v. Nelson39.46 KB 2009AP000004 12/04/2009
Proposals for Settlement
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconCentral PB Physician & Urgent Care v. Progressive Select Ins. Co.254.55 KB 2016AP900225 02/20/2020
PDF iconGeico v. Andy's Auto Body & Paint154.25 KB 2020CA003318 05/24/2021
Replevin
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconPalm Beach County Sheriff's Office v. Read107.02 KB 2006AP000093 08/02/2007
PDF iconRoberts v. Palm Beach County Sheriff's Office137.81 KB 20016AP9000033 07/29/2009
Sanctions
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconUSAA v. Advanced Diagnostic Resources57.75 KB 2013AP000093 08/02/2014
PDF iconG & R Plumbing v Avatar Property1.3 MB 2017AP000051 02/05/2019
PDF iconGraeves v. Avatar Property & Casualty Ins.171.6 KB 2018AP000160 11/23/2020
Service of Process
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconBank of America v. Saint-Vil74.19 KB 2006AP000036 03/02/2007
PDF iconCarmona v. White137.56 KB 2006AP000059 03/26/2007
PDF iconBank of America v. Yates8.23 MB 2006AP000036 06/02/2009
PDF iconMassimo Family v. Scott Corgon Realty99.48 KB 2013AP000032 05/14/2014
PDF iconBody Details v. Harrington136.08 KB 2013AP00058 08/15/2014
PDF iconNorthfield Holding v. Claire Yassa306.11 KB 2014AP000022 05/12/2015
PDF iconHo v. Fountains of Palm Beach136.94 KB 2015AP000041 02/08/2016
PDF iconHenry D. Friedman v. Kirk Bielsky163.71 KB 2014AP000076 06/08/2016
PDF iconBarnes v. Capital One Bank871.37 KB 2017AP000115 08/27/2018
Settlement
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconAjoy v. State Farm28.3 KB 2006AP000087 09/12/2007
PDF iconJoseph v. Citizens Property Insurance Co.1.06 MB 2017AP000131 09/06/2018
PDF iconBivins v. PBCHA211.35 KB 2019AP000018 05/06/2020
Sham Pleadings
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconRamirez v. Atlantic Aluminum, Inc.817.15 KB 2007AP000157 09/08/2008
Trade Secrets
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconGold Coast Chiropractic Center v. State Farm137.57 KB 2015CA002654 10/20/2015
Credit Card
Damages
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconCapital One Bank v. Ciaccia55.33 KB 2016AP000095 08/02/2007
PDF iconCapital One Bank v. Ciaccia36.72 KB 2006AP000095 08/17/2007
PDF iconNational Revenue Service v. USA Johnson31.83 KB 2006AP000094 10/02/2007
Usuary
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconCapital One Bank v. Cox59.04 KB 2006AP000090 08/02/2007
Criminal
Amended Information
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconLeroy Patterson v. State of Florida222.58 KB 2012AP000094 05/21/2015
Check Points/Road Blocks
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconSchleter v. State207.07 KB 2007AO900031 09/10/2008
PDF iconState of Florida v. Wing137.04 KB 2010AO900068 09/16/2011
Citizen Arrest
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconState of Florida v. Ford178.13 KB 2010AP900064 05/14/2010
PDF iconEstrada v. State of Florida232.17 KB 2010AP900057 10/12/2011
Closing Arguments
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconGentry v. State of Florida1.05 MB 2015AP900022 04/25/2017
PDF iconBaker v. State of Florida2.73 MB 2017AP000006 01/14/2020
Contempt
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconCarter v. State of Florida262.31 KB 2018AP000048 07/01/2020
Contributing to the Delinquency of Minor
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconState of Florida v. Razz36.35 KB 2009AP900064 05/14/2010
Correction of Judgment
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconBatton v. State of Florida194.91 KB 2018AP000155 05/15/2020
PDF iconCastellon v. State of Florida192.74 KB 2019AP0000112 07/15/2020
Court Costs
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconYeager-Fischer v. State of Florida599.19 KB 2016AP9000010 08/03/2017
Criminal Mischief
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconDorsett v State of Florida1.09 MB 2017AP000132 02/06/2019
Discovery Violations
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconShannon v. State of Florida2.49 MB 2017AP000101 07/26/2018
PDF iconMazariegos v State of Florida1.52 MB 2015AP900056 02/05/2019
Dismissal
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconState of Florida v. Cohen107.17 KB 2009AP900078 09/29/2010
Double Jeopardy
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconMalcolm v State of Florida986.83 KB 2017AP000032 10/29/2018
Driver's License Restriction
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconSamuels v. State of Florida130.45 KB 2012AP900094 08/28/2014
Evidence
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconGerard v. State of Florida254.13 KB 05-78AC A02 06/14/2006
PDF iconTurner v. State of Florida272.01 KB 05-61AC A02 06/30/2006
PDF iconLivesay v. State of Florida310.35 KB 06-02AC A02 08/03/2006
PDF iconHenry G. Wieneke, JR v. State of Florida129.65 KB 2013AP900068 05/08/2015
PDF iconMatthew James Hubbard v. State of Florida119.27 KB 2014AP900028 10/23/2015
PDF iconLouis v. State of Florida1.44 MB 2017AP000049 07/26/2018
PDF iconRemy v. State of Florida1.68 MB 2018AP000021 06/21/2019
PDF iconDebonville v. State of Florida184.05 KB 2019AP000083 06/11/2020
Ineffective Assistance of Counsel
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconWatson v. State of Florida111.81 KB 2012AP900027 04/08/2014
PDF iconHall v. State of Florida30.16 KB 2012AP900050 07/08/2014
Judgment of Acquittal
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconState of Florida v. Williams1.74 MB 2012AP900030 09/27/2013
PDF iconState of Florida v. Allison677.37 KB 2016AP900039 03/06/2018
PDF iconState of Florida v. Niman834.61 KB 2016AP900256 06/11/2018
Jurors
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconFigueroa v. State of Florida83.31 KB 2013AP900022 09/22/2014
PDF iconHowle v. State of Florida119.94 KB 2014AP900046 02/02/2016
PDF iconShelton v. State of Florida1.26 MB 2016AP900257 12/07/2017
Jury Instructions
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconNarinseing v. State of Florida1.86 MB 2017AP000118 04/22/2019
PDF iconFinney v. State of Florida97.07 KB 2018AP000067 11/30/2020
Jury Trial
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconSlaughter v. State of Florida141.65 KB 2013AP900018 08/06/2014